Strategy guide

The Smith Manoeuvre

How Canadian homeowners turn their mortgage into a tax-deductible investment loan, without paying more each month.

Your mortgage, working as an investment loan

In Canada, the interest on the mortgage for the home you live in isn't tax-deductible. Interest on money borrowed to invest generally is. The Smith Manoeuvre is a way to move your debt from the first kind to the second, a little every month, without paying more than you already do.

The idea behind it

The strategy is named after Fraser Smith, a Canadian financial planner who wrote about it in the early 2000s. His point was simple: most homeowners spend 25 years paying down a debt that gives them nothing back at tax time, and only start investing once it's gone.

The Smith Manoeuvre does both at once. Every dollar of principal you pay off is borrowed back right away and invested. Your mortgage still shrinks on schedule, but a portfolio grows beside it, funded by money that was already leaving your account.

The rule it's built on

Interest is generally deductible when borrowed money is used to earn income from property, such as dividends or interest. CRA's Income Tax Folio S3-F6-C1, Interest Deductibility looks at what the borrowed money was directly used for. The Supreme Court of Canada's Ludco decision (2001) is the one usually pointed to here: an investment can qualify even if income isn't your main goal, so long as it's reasonable to expect some. Borrowing purely in hope of a capital gain isn't enough on its own.

That's why the investments are usually income-producing, held in a non-registered account, and bought with a line of credit used for nothing else.

What you end up with

At the end, you owe roughly what you owed at the start. The difference is that none of it is a personal mortgage any more. It's an investment loan whose interest you can deduct, and against it you own a portfolio you built along the way.

Each spring the tax refund on that interest goes onto the mortgage too, so the conversion finishes years before a regular mortgage would be paid off.

Where the benefit comes from

There are two engines. The first is the tax refund: each year, part of your interest comes back and pays down more of the mortgage. The second is the portfolio itself, which has decades to grow and pay income.

On the other side is the interest on the line. The strategy comes out ahead when what the investments earn, plus the refunds, beats that interest over the long run. Borrowing to invest magnifies results in both directions, which is why time is your friend here.

Ways to speed it up

The basic version converts your mortgage as fast as you pay it down. Some people add fuel. A debt swap converts a chunk on day one using non-registered investments you already own. Rental Cash Damming uses rent to pay the home mortgage down faster. Even putting every refund straight back on the mortgage makes a real difference over the years.

The walk-through

The Smith Manoeuvre, step by step

Named after Fraser Smith, the Canadian planner who popularized it. Here's how it runs, from the first meeting to a fully converted mortgage.

  1. Before you start

    Make sure the foundation is there

    You'll need at least 20% equity in your home, steady income, an emergency fund and a time horizon of ten years or more. The plan holds investments through good markets and bad ones, so you need to be comfortable staying put when they drop.

  2. Set-up

    Switch to a readvanceable mortgage

    Your mortgage is set up as a regular amortizing portion plus a line of credit. Each time you pay down principal, the line's limit goes up by the same amount. Renewal is usually the cheapest time to make the switch.

  3. Set-up

    Open a separate investment line and account

    The line used for investing is kept only for investing, and the investments go into a non-registered account. Your wealth advisor picks a portfolio that is expected to earn income, like dividends or interest, which is what makes the interest deductible.

  4. Every month

    Pay down, re-borrow, invest

    Your regular payment knocks down some principal. The same amount opens up on the line, and you borrow it and invest it. Your total debt stays about the same, but each month more of it is deductible investment debt and less of it is your home.

    Many people also pay the line's interest from the line itself, so nothing extra comes out of their pocket. Your accountant can confirm how that's tracked.

  5. Every spring

    The refund goes back to work

    The interest on the investment line is claimed as a carrying charge on your tax return. The refund goes onto the mortgage as a prepayment, which opens up more room on the line to invest.

  6. Down the road

    The mortgage is fully converted

    Eventually there's no non-deductible mortgage left. You owe roughly what you did at the start, but all of it is deductible, and you own a portfolio built with money that was already leaving your account.

    Some people speed this up with a debt swap or cash damming on top. Mitch looks at those on the first call.

Common mistakes

  • Co-mingling. Using the investment line for anything personal, even a small draw.
  • No tracking. Not keeping records that show each draw went straight into investments.
  • No time horizon. Starting without 10 years or more to ride out market drops.

Is it a fit?

The Smith Manoeuvre is a long-term plan. It works best with a few things in place.

Good fit

  • You own your home
  • You have at least 20% equity in it
  • You plan to stay invested for 15 years or more

Probably not yet

  • A market drop would push you to sell
  • You plan to sell and rent in the next few years
  • You can't commit to keeping the accounts organized every month

Smith Manoeuvre questions

Anything about your own tax situation should also go past your accountant.

Why is the interest deductible?

Interest is generally deductible when borrowed money is used to earn income, such as dividends or interest. The line of credit is used only to buy income-producing investments, so its interest can be deducted. Investments that don't pay income, or mixing personal spending into the line, can put the deduction at risk.

What do I invest in?

That's a decision for you and a licensed financial advisor. The investments need a reasonable expectation of income, like dividends or interest, for the interest to be deductible. Mitch handles the mortgage and structure and works alongside the advisor and your accountant so the pieces fit together.

What if the market drops?

Your investment loan stays the same while the portfolio falls, and the plan only works if you can hold through it. That's why it suits long time horizons and steady incomes.

Does my debt go up?

Your total debt stays the same as you pay the mortgage down, because every dollar of principal is re-borrowed. The difference is that the new debt is deductible and you own a portfolio against it.

What kind of mortgage do I need?

A readvanceable mortgage, where the line of credit grows automatically as you pay the mortgage down. Setup, fees and limits vary by lender, and choosing the right one is a big part of what Mitch does.

See it on your own numbers

Do your free Debt Audit and see it on your own numbers. In 15 minutes Mitch will tell you whether it fits and what mortgage you'd need.